Comparison

Profound vs Scrunch AI vs AthenaHQ: Which AEO Tools Tool Should You Choose in 2026?

Profound, Scrunch AI and AthenaHQ all solve aeo tools problems, but in different ways. Here's how their pricing, features and ideal users actually compare.

Profound vs Scrunch AI vs AthenaHQ at a glance

ToolProfoundScrunch AIAthenaHQ
TaglineEnterprise AI search visibility tracking with AI agents for contentAI visibility monitoring plus hallucination detectionAI search visibility tracking with a free entry plan and credit-based pricing
PricingFree trial (50 prompts, daily for 7 days, 3 engines); Enterprise is custom-quoted. An Agency Growth self-serve plan exists but its price is not shown. Previously listed Starter ($99) and Growth ($399) plans no longer appear on the pricing page.No free plan; 7-day free trial of Starter (no card). Starter $250/mo billed annually ($300 monthly); Growth $417/mo annually ($500 monthly); Enterprise custom. Extra seats $25/mo each.Free Essential plan (300 credits, 5 engines). Starter $295/mo (3,600 credits, 11 models; annual billing listed as 17% off, annual price not shown). Enterprise custom. API access and extra credits cost extra.
Rating—G2 4.6/5 (74 reviews (G2, checked 2026-11-02))G2 4.9/5 (39 reviews (G2, checked 2026-11-02))
Key features
  • Answer Engine Insights: visibility, citations and sentiment across AI engines
  • Prompt Volumes research on what people ask AI tools
  • Agents and Context Manager for content work, credit-metered
  • Agent Analytics for AI crawler and referral traffic
  • Prompt, topic and entity tracking across ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Perplexity, Google AI Mode/Overviews and Meta
  • Citation analysis showing which sources AI relies on
  • Real-time feed of AI bot crawls and crawl-error detection
  • Competitor, persona, topic and geo benchmarking
  • Visibility, citation and share-of-voice tracking (5 engines on free Essential; 11 models on Starter)
  • Competitor monitoring and content gap identification
  • Citation source analysis and link-building guidance
  • Content optimization agent and recommendations
Pros
  • Wide engine coverage on Enterprise (up to 9 engines)
  • Connects monitoring to content agents in one product
  • SSO/SAML and SOC 2 on Enterprise
  • All core features on every plan; tiers differ mainly by volume
  • Bot-crawl monitoring plus citation analysis in one tool
  • Backing from a larger company after the Sitecore acquisition
  • Real free plan, not a time-limited trial
  • Broad model coverage on Starter (11)
  • Unlimited seats on all plans
Cons
  • Public self-serve pricing is gone or hidden; Enterprise is quote-only
  • The free trial is short (7 days of daily tracking) and locked to a recommended prompt set
  • Agent usage is metered in credits, so costs can be hard to predict
  • Pricey entry point with no free plan, only a 7-day trial
  • Hallucination-detection claims from earlier copy could not be verified on the live site
  • Seat, prompt and persona caps are tight on Starter; extra seats cost $25/mo each
  • Acquisition makes standalone pricing and roadmap less certain
  • Credit metering makes monthly cost harder to predict
  • API access and extra credits are paid add-ons
  • Free plan covers only 5 engines and 300 credits
  • Annual price and add-on prices are not shown on the pricing page
Best forMid-size and enterprise marketing teams that need broad AI-engine monitoring and are ready to budget through a sales process.Mid-market and enterprise marketing teams that want prompt tracking, citation analysis and bot-crawl data in one paid platform, particularly Sitecore users.Startups and lean teams who want to test AI visibility tracking for free and grow spend with usage.

About Profound

Profound tracks how brands appear in AI answer engines such as ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Claude and Google AI Overviews, and pairs that data with agents that help produce and update content. It now describes itself as an AI marketing platform.

Pricing: Free trial (50 prompts, daily for 7 days, 3 engines); Enterprise is custom-quoted. An Agency Growth self-serve plan exists but its price is not shown. Previously listed Starter ($99) and Growth ($399) plans no longer appear on the pricing page.

Read the full Profound review →

About Scrunch AI

Scrunch is an AI search visibility platform that tracks how brands appear in AI answers across ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Perplexity, Google AI Mode/Overviews and Meta, shows which sources AI cites, monitors AI bot crawls, and offers AXP, a machine-readable site layer for AI agents. Sitecore announced its acquisition of Scrunch in 2026.

Pricing: No free plan; 7-day free trial of Starter (no card). Starter $250/mo billed annually ($300 monthly); Growth $417/mo annually ($500 monthly); Enterprise custom. Extra seats $25/mo each.

Read the full Scrunch AI review →

About AthenaHQ

AthenaHQ is an answer engine optimization platform that tracks brand mentions, citations and share of voice across AI engines, then recommends on-page and off-page fixes. Usage is metered in credits, with a free Essential plan to start.

Pricing: Free Essential plan (300 credits, 5 engines). Starter $295/mo (3,600 credits, 11 models; annual billing listed as 17% off, annual price not shown). Enterprise custom. API access and extra credits cost extra.

Read the full AthenaHQ review →

Quick picks

Frequently asked questions

Which is cheaper: Profound, Scrunch AI or AthenaHQ?

Based on published pricing: Profound (Free trial (50 prompts, daily for 7 days, 3 engines); Enterprise is custom-quoted. An Agency Growth self-serve plan exists but its price is not shown. Previously listed Starter ($99) and Growth ($399) plans no longer appear on the pricing page.); Scrunch AI (No free plan; 7-day free trial of Starter (no card). Starter $250/mo billed annually ($300 monthly); Growth $417/mo annually ($500 monthly); Enterprise custom. Extra seats $25/mo each.); AthenaHQ (Free Essential plan (300 credits, 5 engines). Starter $295/mo (3,600 credits, 11 models; annual billing listed as 17% off, annual price not shown). Enterprise custom. API access and extra credits cost extra.). Exact value depends on your usage volume and which features you actually need, so check each tool's full pricing breakdown before deciding.

Which of these three has the best reviews?

Scrunch AI shows G2 4.6/5 (74 reviews (G2, checked 2026-11-02)). AthenaHQ shows G2 4.9/5 (39 reviews (G2, checked 2026-11-02)). Weigh this alongside the feature and pricing comparison above, not as the only factor.

Which has the most features: Profound, Scrunch AI or AthenaHQ?

Of the three, AthenaHQ lists the most features in our comparison above, though more features doesn't automatically mean it's the better fit — a simpler, more focused tool can win for a specific use case.

Can I use more than one of these aeo tools tools together?

Yes — many teams run more than one aeo tools tool for different parts of their workflow rather than picking a single winner. Start with whichever one matches your primary use case, and add a second only if you hit a real gap.

More AEO Tools comparisons

Want to compare different tools?

Use our interactive Compare tool to pick any aeo tools tools yourself, or browse the full category.

Open this comparison in Compare tool →

See all AEO Tools tools on ToolScout.